Sales training · 5 min read
How to Manage an Underperforming Salesperson, Step by Step
Learn how to manage an underperforming salesperson: diagnose the cause, set a clear improvement plan, coach weekly and decide fairly when it is not working.
Agent Guru
Rehearsed before the first buyer.
Every salesperson practises the real pitch on their phone. The AI coach names what they missed, and you see who is ready.
Book a free demoSee how it worksEvery sales manager eventually has to manage an underperforming salesperson. It is one of the hardest parts of the job, because the numbers are visible, the stakes are personal and the team is watching. Handled well, it can save a good rep. Handled badly, it costs you the rep and the trust of the team.
This article gives you a clear sequence: diagnose before you decide, have an honest conversation, set a short improvement plan, coach weekly and make a fair decision at the end.

Diagnose before you act
Do not assume the rep is lazy or unskilled. Look at the evidence first. Underperformance usually has one of five causes.
- Skill: the rep does not know how to do something, such as discovery or handling objections
- Knowledge: they have outdated or incomplete facts about the offer
- Will: low motivation, burnout or a personal issue
- Fit: the role, territory or product does not match their strengths
- System: bad leads, tool problems or a confusing plan
Check the data: activity, conversion by stage, call quality and readiness. Listen to calls. Ask the rep. The cause decides the cure. The skill and will matrix in sales coaching models for managers can help you sort cases.
Be honest with yourself too. Ask whether you have given this rep the same coaching, leads and clarity as others. If the answer is no, part of the problem may be yours, and fixing it is the fastest way to help.
Have the honest conversation early
Do not wait for the quarter to end. A private, calm conversation as soon as you see a pattern is kinder than a surprise review.
- State the facts: here is what I see in the numbers and in the calls
- Ask for their view: what is getting in the way
- Say what good looks like, in specific terms
- Offer support: what I will do to help
- Agree a follow-up date
Stay factual and avoid labels. Say your pitch conversion has dropped since March, not you are not trying. Listen carefully, because you may learn about a lead issue or a personal problem that changes the plan.
Choose the time and place with care. A private room or a quiet video call, with enough time and no interruptions, shows respect. End the meeting with something encouraging that is also true, such as a strength you value in their work.
Write a short, specific improvement plan
A plan of thirty to sixty days is usually enough to see movement. Make it simple and written, with a copy for the rep.
- Two or three measurable goals, such as number of qualified conversations and conversion at one stage
- One or two skills to practise, with how and how often
- Support you will give: weekly coaching, call review, a buddy
- Check-in dates and what will be reviewed
- What happens at the end of the period
Check with HR before using any formal process, as rules differ by country and company. In the USA, documentation matters for legal reasons. In the UAE and India, labour rules and notice periods vary, so involve HR early and keep clear records.
Link each goal to a behaviour the rep controls. Rather than close two more deals, aim for ten qualified conversations a week and a next step agreed in every call. Behaviour goals are fairer and easier to coach.
Coach weekly and track progress
A plan without coaching is only paperwork. Meet weekly, review one call and practise one skill. Focus on small improvements that the rep can see.
- Replay a recent call and pick one moment to improve
- Role-play the moment until it feels natural
- Ask the rep to try it on the next three calls and report back
- Recognise progress openly, even if small
Read sales role-play exercises for teams for ideas that keep practice practical and not embarrassing. Many underperforming reps turn out to lack confidence in specific parts of the pitch, and repeated rehearsal makes a visible difference.
Share the improvement in numbers and in behaviour. If conversion has not moved yet but the rep now asks better discovery questions, say so. Seeing progress in what they do keeps them going while the results catch up.
Decide fairly at the end
At the end of the plan, review the evidence together. There are three outcomes.
- Improved: confirm it, thank the rep and keep coaching
- Partly improved: extend with a clear final target
- Not improved: consider a different role, a transfer or ending the employment, following your HR process
If the answer is to part ways, do it respectfully and promptly. Letting a poor fit drag on harms the rest of the team and the rep. Be honest with the rest of the team about what they need to know, without sharing private details.
Document every step in factual language: dates, conversations, goals, support given and results. Good records protect both the rep and the company, and they make the final decision clearer for everyone.
Protect the team while you do this
Other reps notice how you handle underperformance. If you ignore it, high performers feel that effort does not matter. If you handle it harshly, everyone feels unsafe. Aim for a clear standard applied kindly and consistently.
Keep up recognition for strong work during this period, and do not let the struggling rep absorb all your attention. Keep your regular coaching routine for the rest of the team.
Closing knowledge and confidence gaps with Agent Guru
Many cases come down to knowledge and confidence. With Agent Guru, a struggling rep can rehearse the approved pitch out loud on their own phone, as often as they like, without anyone watching. The AI scores it and names what was missed or wrong, such as wrong facts, wrong order or the wrong payment plan, and the manager sees progress in the team view.
This gives your improvement plan objective evidence, and gives the rep a private place to rebuild confidence. See managing a property sales team and coach property salespeople.
Frequently asked questions
How do you manage an underperforming salesperson?
Diagnose the cause first: skill, knowledge, motivation, fit or system. Have an early, factual conversation, agree a short written plan with measurable goals, coach weekly, and review the evidence at the end. Involve HR, and make a fair decision based on progress.
How long should a sales performance improvement plan last?
Thirty to sixty days is common, long enough to see real change and short enough to keep focus. Set clear goals, weekly check-ins and a review date. Rules vary by country and employer, so check your HR policy and local labour law before you begin.
What if a salesperson is not hitting quota because of leads?
Check the data first. If lead quality or quantity is the issue, fix the system rather than blame the rep. Compare conversion on leads across reps, look at response times and listen to calls. If the leads are fine and the rep still struggles, look at skills and knowledge.
Should I tell the team about a rep's performance plan?
No. Keep the details private. Tell the team only what they need to know to do their work, such as changes to coverage. The way you handle the situation, with fairness and respect, is what the team will notice and remember.
Give every salesperson an AI coach that listens
Your team rehearses the real pitch on their phones, the AI names what they missed, and you see who is ready before they meet a buyer.

